UNP WEEKLY

I had a lengthy conversation on Friday with a young chap who happened to work at a hedge fund, while I was eating at a New York style pizza joint in Glasgow, Scotland. This was after a required meeting to gain my right to permanent residency in the U.K. The meeting was pure coincidence. He saw me looking at my charts while I was eating.
We got to talking about MACD. My point to him was while weekly MACD is currently crossed over down it was time to be short or in cash. He offered his views, but he was more of short term trader, scalper, day trader.
We looked at many charts while he tried to test my theory in a socratic manner. My theory to him was from a intermediate time frame and that while weekly MACD was crossed over down one should be short or in cash. Sometimes I am nimble will take a shorter term trade if conditions are right for me. Thus he pointed out that the market lately was not conducive to intermediate time frame trading, to which I concurred.
We then started looking at daily charts and comparing them to weekly charts in terms of MACD. Such as MACD can be crossed over up on a daily chart, but crossed over down on the weekly. My point was when this occurs they are short term long trades to the upside, but the larger more dominant trend will assert itself and the selling will pick up again, leading to lower prices.
One thing that I thing I think he walked away with at the very least was a new perspective regarding time frames.
We looked at many charts but the ones we focused on were the major indices and the rails. My focus was on the most recent bull from 03-07, as I think this is the most relevant for many reasons, but I will not labor this article with them at this time, because he did quiz me regarding decades of data and charts and why I think the most recent bull is the most relevant. If one looks at the SPY MACD history during the 03-07 bull market period, it was very predicative when to sell, get in cash or put on some hedges to protect your longs. As long as MACD is crossed over down the sell side was dominant and the daily MACD cross overs up are nothing more than counter trend rally's in the dominant time frame. Sometimes they even made new highs while weekly MACD was crossed over down and never crossed over up confirming the daily or weekly strength. Why not just be patient and wait for weekly MACD to cross over up then you know you are on the side of the dominant trade. The only caveat for buying on weekly MACD cross over down is you feel Mr. Market is mis pricing an equity or they are throwing the baby out with the bath water, this I can not argue against it. I just hope you have done your own DD.
Currently, for me I do have some longs for this attempt at recent highs, but I have spent most of my time strategically adding to short positions.
I also sold some of my miners that had nice gains, still have a few I am being patient with, but the leash is getting short.
One final thing is my wife is giving birth to our second child tomorrow, so I will update as I can, but for now I am adding to shorts at low risk points and the market will have to prove me wrong and take me out and that wont happen unless prices make new highs and weekly MACD confirms.